South Africa Faces Growing Security Threat as Highly Skilled Police Officers Exit SAPS for Private Sector
Viable News Team 
South Africa is facing a worrying trend that experts warn could weaken national security: the steady migration of highly trained police officers from the South African Police Service (SAPS) into the private security industry and in some cases, into the hands of criminal syndicates.
The concern has intensified following shocking allegations against Matipandile Sotheni, a former member of the SAPS elite Special Task Force (STF), who is accused of participating in organised crime, including the hit on former Ekurhuleni Metro Police reservist Marius van der Merwe. Van der Merwe was murdered shortly after giving explosive testimony at the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry, where he implicated senior EMPD officials in the controversial death of Emmanuel Mbense.
Sotheni’s alleged involvement has triggered an urgent national conversation: Is South Africa unknowingly training elite officers who later use their skills outside the law or even against the state they once served?
A Dangerous Trend Exposed
The movement of specialised officers from SAPS to the private sector is not new. But the Sotheni case has cast the trend in a far more troubling light.
Crime expert Chad Thomas describes the situation as “exceptionally concerning,” warning that organised crime networks aggressively target former STF members for their rare, high-level combat and tactical expertise.
“These members are not ordinary officers they are some of the most highly trained operatives in the country,” Thomas said.
He added that the pattern mirrors previous cases, noting that the controversial businessman Vusimuzi ‘Cat’ Matlala once hired former STF members to protect his illegal blue-light brigade.
This intersection of elite policing skills and criminal operations, Thomas warns, represents a growing and deeply dangerous convergence.
Institutional Risk, Not Yet a National Security Collapse — But Close
Parliament’s Police Portfolio Committee chairperson Ian Cameron acknowledges the seriousness of the situation but cautions against describing it as a national security threat at least for now.
“I would not describe the movement of Special Task Force members into the private sector as a national security risk yet, but it is a serious institutional concern,” Cameron said.
He explained that STF members undergo extensive state-funded training, costing millions of rands, designed to prepare them for extreme high-risk environments such as hostage rescues, counterterrorism operations, and violent crime takedowns.
“The vast majority join because of a deep sense of duty,” he said. “That’s why the state must take responsibility for retaining and supporting this capability.”
Cameron stressed that without strong integrity checks and proper retention strategies, SAPS risks hollowing out its most vital units leaving South Africa exposed.
Why Skilled Officers Are Leaving: Money, Equipment, Conditions
Anti-crime activist Yusuf Abramjee says the reasons behind the exodus are not mysterious: officers are simply leaving for greener pastures.
“The reality is that many of these officers leave because of better remuneration, improved working conditions, and access to resources they do not have within SAPS,” Abramjee said.
He emphasised three major issues:
1. Poor Remuneration
Specialised officers often carry enormous risk but receive salaries that do not match their responsibilities.
2. Harsh Working Conditions
Many STF members operate with outdated equipment, poor support structures, and inadequate mental-health resources.
3. Lack of Career Growth
Talented officers sometimes feel undervalued or blocked by political interference and institutional instability.
Abramjee warns that while many officers retain integrity even after leaving, the lure of lucrative offers from criminal syndicates is real and dangerous.
Is the Problem Getting Worse? Experts Say There’s Not Enough Data
According to security analyst David Bruce, it remains unclear whether the outflow of elite officers has accelerated.
Bruce notes that the issue was raised as far back as 2024, prompting SAPS to increase the scarce-skills allowance for STF members from R6,000 to R21,000 per month a significant jump meant to stem the losses. Yet its impact remains uncertain.
What is clear, however, is that crime involving former police officers and even current ones is on the rise.
“There is a problem of former SAPS members who have become involved in violent crime,” Bruce said. “But this is not limited to former members we have also seen it among officers still serving.”
A Country Caught Between Two Battles
South Africa now faces a dual challenge:
- Retaining elite officers essential for national safety, and
- Preventing those who leave from being absorbed into criminal or rogue security networks.
With the private security industry continuing to boom and organised crime evolving into more sophisticated networks — SAPS is locked in a battle for talent, loyalty, and integrity.
The Sotheni case has served as a wake-up call. But whether the state will respond with meaningful reforms or continue losing its most capable warriors remains an open and urgent question.
About the Author
